The Match-Play Trophy was started in 2004, the centenary of the Society. It is a handicap knock-out event. The trophy is a Victorian salver presented by Philip Langford, the organiser.
| Year | Winner |
|---|---|
| 2004 | Jamie Hudson beat Andrew Barrow in the final |
| 2005 | Jeremy Caplan beat Stuart Murray |
| 2006 | Brian Gegg beat Stuart Murray |
| 2007 | Christopher Johnson-Gilbert beat Bill Richards |
| 2008 | Tim Russell beat John Hagan |
| 2009 | Grant Needham beat Roger Davies |